Martha Peterson

Mr. Warnasch worked with the local community to tentatively identify the Queens woman as Martha Peterson and has uncovered several tantalizing clues regarding her life.

Martha Peterson

The body of an African American woman was discovered in 2011 in Elmhurst, Queens, as part of what was originally thought to be a potential crime scene. It was determined that the woman, who had been buried in a Fisk coffin, died of small pox. Based on historical records, she has been tentatively identified as Martha Peterson, who was born in 1824 and died around 1851. She was buried in the Dutch Lane churchyard, founded in 1828 by the first generation of fully emancipated African Americans in Queens. Records suggest that she may have been taught by escaped slave, minister, educator and abolitionist James W. C. Pennington.

More information to come.

 

Queens lady lesions
Martha Peterson’s Arm Lesions – Small Pox
Map of Newtown, Queens, circa 1873 showing the churchyard where Martha was buried and school house she likely attended
queens lady pointed toes
Hammertoes indicate she wore shoes that were either pointed or too small
Queens Lady Stockings | Photo credit: John Wozniak
Martha Peterson’s Stockings | Photo credit: John Wozniak
Scott Warnasche archeologist
Scene recovery 2011. Photo by Chris Rainwater
Photo by Linda Warnasch
Queens Lady Shroud | Photo credit: John Wozniak
Martha Peterson’s Shroud | Photo credit: John Wozniak
Queens Lady Chemise | Photo credit: John Wozniak
Martha Peterson’s Chemise | Photo credit: John Wozniak
Queens Lady Tortise Shell Hair Comb | Photo credit: John Wozniak
Martha Peterson’s Hair Comb | Photo credit: John Wozniak

In the News

city reporter article screenshot

In the News: New Push to Landmark Paved-Over Queens African Burial Ground

The Landmarks Preservation Commission is reviewing a request to protect the 19th century cemetery of a historic Elmhurst church from development. BY GREG B. SMITH SEPT. 4, 2026, 5:03 A.M. Read the full article on The City Reporter: https://www.thecityreporter.nyc/2026/09/04/LANDMARKS-REQUEST-HISTORIC-BLACK-CHURCH-ST-MARK-AME/

Read More
screenshot of city reporter article

In the News: From Parking Lot to Memorial? Queens Borough Prez Wants City to Buy Paved-Over Black Cemetery

Borough President Donovan Richards will call on the Mamdani administration to turn the former cemetery of a historic Black church into a public-facing memorial. BY GREG B. SMITH SEPT. 2, 2026, 1:33 P.M.Read the full article on The City Reporter: https://www.thecityreporter.nyc/2026/09/02/donovan-richards-queens-african-burial-ground-elmhurst-st-mark/

Read More
screenshot of original news article posted on the city reporter & image of parking lot

In the News: They Paved a Historic NYC Black Burial Ground. Now It’s a Lot for Abandoned Cars.

The bodies of nearly 300 free Black people buried during the 1800s lie under the asphalt in East Elmhurst, Queens. The lot was used by an NYPD towing contractor. BY GREG B. SMITH AUG. 24, 2026, 5:03 A.M.Read the full article on The City Reporter: https://www.thecityreporter.nyc/2026/08/24/nyc-queens-black-african-burial-ground-nypd-parking-lot/

Read More